By now millions of people around the world have seen the on court fight between the players from both teams at the end of the Xavier University – University of Cincinnati basketball game December 10, 2011. (A friend in Thailand saw the video clip on television.) This is a game played between two universities that are approximately 3 miles apart and has been an intense but most enjoyable rivalry for decades called the "Crosstown Shootout". Sandie and I were present at the game and witnessed this repugnant disgusting display of the completely inappropriate attempt to satisfy the human need for power. It was not an attempt to merely achieve which is the more noble component of the power need. It was a violent attempt at power
over others.
Of course this is a highly intellectual analysis of what happens when the emotional component of behavior overtakes the rational component.
It clearly demonstrates that merely “talking things over” is inadequate and constitutes a feeble attempt to resolve differences. Severe consequences are necessary, even punishment. Players involved received suspensions, a process very painful to them but very educational for them.
I wrote the letter below to the Cincinnati Enquirer newspaper which they published on December 12. It clearly shows how choice theory/reality therapy can be used on a community wide and systemic basis. There needs to be some public and symbolic demonstration indicating reconciliation between the offending parties.
My understanding is that there are plans for the two teams to engage in community service together as a joint effort. The team members have already reconciled on a personal basis. Wouldn’t it be exciting if the media gave equal attention to this peace making process!
Letter to the Editor:
Punishment: Necessary but Insufficient
The disgraceful behavior demonstrated at the Cintas Center by both Xavier and University of Cincinnati players has resulted in calls for sanctions and punishment. And while such behavior deserves consequences, force and coercion are not enough.
There should be a public reconciliation ceremony. The teams, university presidents, coaches and athletic directors should appear together in a neutral place, perhaps Fountain Square, and demonstrate their resolve to relinquish their resentment and reinstate their dignity. A neutral person could facilitate this, such as the mayor and community leaders, or several religious leaders. In this way they will show the community, the sports world, and the nation that our universities stand for good sportsmanship and ethical conduct. Pious statements about regret and shame without positive action will be shallow and insufficient.
Robert E. Wubbolding, EdD
Professor, Xavier University (Retired)
Doctoral graduate, University of Cincinnati
Posted by Bob and Sandie Wubbolding